1
00:00:02,235 --> 00:00:02,268
   [i                           

2
00:00:02,268 --> 00:00:02,302
   [int                         

3
00:00:02,302 --> 00:00:02,335
   [intri                       

4
00:00:02,335 --> 00:00:02,369
   [intrigu                     

5
00:00:02,369 --> 00:00:02,402
   [intriguin                   

6
00:00:02,402 --> 00:00:02,435
   [intriguing                  

7
00:00:02,435 --> 00:00:02,469
   [intriguing mu               

8
00:00:02,469 --> 00:00:02,502
   [intriguing musi             

9
00:00:02,502 --> 00:00:03,169
   [intriguing music]           

10
00:00:03,169 --> 00:00:04,237
 - [Alan] In Sarasota, Florida, 

11
00:00:04,237 --> 00:00:07,674
everything and everyone         
   revolves around the arts.    

12
00:00:07,674 --> 00:00:08,808
[dramatic string music]         

13
00:00:08,808 --> 00:00:10,243
   - It was a place             
   where arts lovers            

14
00:00:10,243 --> 00:00:13,246
 can really indulge themselves. 

15
00:00:13,246 --> 00:00:17,550
   - But in 2004, this haven    
  for artists was traumatized   

16
00:00:17,550 --> 00:00:20,553
by the brutal murder of         
 61-year-old gallerist          

17
00:00:20,553 --> 00:00:22,389
 Joyce Wishart.                 

18
00:00:22,389 --> 00:00:24,424
- It was different than         
 any other crime scene          

19
00:00:24,424 --> 00:00:26,426
that we had encountered.        

20
00:00:26,426 --> 00:00:28,294
 This is something that         
  was straight out of,          

21
00:00:28,294 --> 00:00:30,163
 like, a horror movie.          

22
00:00:30,163 --> 00:00:33,533
- A crime scene so twisted that 
  investigators are searching   

23
00:00:33,533 --> 00:00:35,935
 in the darkest                 
   corners for clues.           

24
00:00:35,935 --> 00:00:37,404
[dramatic music]                

25
00:00:37,404 --> 00:00:40,673
- The art behind Joyce's        
 hand had blood on it.          

26
00:00:40,673 --> 00:00:43,276
- We looked at each of          
  those pictures and thought,   

27
00:00:43,276 --> 00:00:46,813
  "Is there a clue in           
 any of these paintings         

28
00:00:46,813 --> 00:00:49,682
  that lead us to the killer?"  

29
00:00:49,682 --> 00:00:51,718
- Could an evil artist be hiding

30
00:00:51,718 --> 00:00:53,420
 in this tight-knit community?  

31
00:00:53,420 --> 00:00:54,954
[dramatic music]                

32
00:00:54,954 --> 00:00:58,324
 - The arts community           
 went into panic mode.          

33
00:00:58,324 --> 00:01:00,693
 Everyone was walking           
on eggshells with fear.         

34
00:01:00,693 --> 00:01:02,328
[dramatic music]                

35
00:01:02,328 --> 00:01:04,564
  - And that deeply-connected   
community is now looking around 

36
00:01:04,564 --> 00:01:05,698
and wondering...                

37
00:01:05,698 --> 00:01:07,300
[dramatic music]                

38
00:01:07,300 --> 00:01:11,571
  if it could be one of their   
  own painting the town red.    

39
00:01:11,571 --> 00:01:14,908
[dramatic string music]         

40
00:01:21,481 --> 00:01:23,850
[dramatic string                
music continues]                

41
00:01:23,850 --> 00:01:26,553
 [eerie music]                  

42
00:01:47,740 --> 00:02:00,220
 [eerie music]                  

43
00:02:00,887 --> 00:02:02,789
 [eerie music]                  

44
00:02:02,789 --> 00:02:05,658
  - The 911 call came in about  
   a little after one o'clock   

45
00:02:05,658 --> 00:02:07,494
   in the afternoon.            

46
00:02:07,494 --> 00:02:10,497
   Certainly, when the caller   
  eventually describes          

47
00:02:10,497 --> 00:02:14,634
   that the person is           
 green and laying nude,         

48
00:02:14,634 --> 00:02:17,770
   you realize this is going    
   to be probably a homicide.   

49
00:02:17,770 --> 00:02:19,639
   [intriguing music]           

50
00:02:19,639 --> 00:02:21,674
  Myself and Detective Glover,  

51
00:02:21,674 --> 00:02:24,644
 the three of us then rode over 
  to the crime scene together.  

52
00:02:24,644 --> 00:02:26,646
   [intriguing music]           

53
00:02:26,646 --> 00:02:28,915
- [Police] Okay, we have        
[indistinct] coming out there...

54
00:02:28,915 --> 00:02:30,917
   [intriguing music]           

55
00:02:30,917 --> 00:02:33,386
  The crime scene was           
  Provenance Gallery.           

56
00:02:33,386 --> 00:02:38,057
 It's a unit along Palm Avenue  
 with some other art dealers.   

57
00:02:38,057 --> 00:02:39,526
   [intriguing music]           

58
00:02:39,526 --> 00:02:41,060
  - There were several          
  restaurants around,           

59
00:02:41,060 --> 00:02:45,398
   there were other galleries   
 and boutiques around,          

60
00:02:45,398 --> 00:02:47,800
and it was a quiet part of town.

61
00:02:47,800 --> 00:02:49,435
   [intriguing music]           

62
00:02:49,435 --> 00:02:51,804
- [Mark] When we arrived, we did
  proceed into the crime scene  

63
00:02:51,804 --> 00:02:53,806
 to view it ourselves.          

64
00:02:53,806 --> 00:02:56,676
- [Police] Okay, we have        
[indistinct] coming out there...

65
00:02:56,676 --> 00:02:59,979
  - The first thing that hits   
  you in the face is the odor.  

66
00:02:59,979 --> 00:03:01,714
It is powerful.                 

67
00:03:01,714 --> 00:03:04,951
And once you've smelled         
   it, you can never forget.    

68
00:03:04,951 --> 00:03:08,454
  - [Mark] Also, there was the  
   sound of classical music,    

69
00:03:08,454 --> 00:03:11,858
 which was playing at the same  
  time, which was very eerie.   

70
00:03:11,858 --> 00:03:15,094
  [dramatic orchestral music]   

71
00:03:15,094 --> 00:03:17,463
  One of the things we know as  
  soon as we came in, though,   

72
00:03:17,463 --> 00:03:19,432
   there was no scene           
 of a struggle.                 

73
00:03:19,432 --> 00:03:21,601
  [dramatic orchestral music]   

74
00:03:21,601 --> 00:03:24,103
   Everything looked            
completely fine                 

75
00:03:24,103 --> 00:03:25,705
 walking into the art gallery.  

76
00:03:25,705 --> 00:03:27,006
  [dramatic orchestral music]   

77
00:03:27,006 --> 00:03:29,108
  - [Suzanne] We find the body  
  lying on the ground           

78
00:03:29,108 --> 00:03:32,011
 in between two partition walls 

79
00:03:32,011 --> 00:03:35,481
where she can't be seen         
 from the front door,           

80
00:03:35,481 --> 00:03:37,617
   and she's laying face up.    

81
00:03:37,617 --> 00:03:39,118
  [dramatic orchestral music]   

82
00:03:39,118 --> 00:03:41,354
   - [Alan] The maintenance     
   worker who found the body    

83
00:03:41,354 --> 00:03:42,889
knows exactly who it is.        

84
00:03:42,889 --> 00:03:44,724
 [eerie music]                  

85
00:03:44,724 --> 00:03:47,493
   Provenance Gallery owner,    
   61-year-old Joyce Wishart.   

86
00:03:47,493 --> 00:03:51,130
 [eerie music]                  

87
00:03:51,130 --> 00:03:52,632
   in the exact area.           

88
00:03:52,632 --> 00:03:54,901
  That was the only area that   
had anything disturbed.         

89
00:03:54,901 --> 00:03:57,470
 [eerie music]                  

90
00:03:57,470 --> 00:04:01,374
- [Suzanne] She was already in a
   state that indicated to us   

91
00:04:01,374 --> 00:04:04,010
 that she had been dead         
   probably for several days.   

92
00:04:04,010 --> 00:04:05,478
 [eerie music]                  

93
00:04:05,478 --> 00:04:08,481
 So that was a starting         
 point for a timeframe          

94
00:04:08,481 --> 00:04:10,049
   of when to start looking.    

95
00:04:10,049 --> 00:04:14,887
 [eerie music]                  

96
00:04:14,887 --> 00:04:17,657
 And then, as I walked          
  closer to her body,           

97
00:04:17,657 --> 00:04:20,026
she had pairs of shoes,         

98
00:04:20,026 --> 00:04:22,795
 which were now pointed         
  in towards her body.          

99
00:04:22,795 --> 00:04:25,498
 Her legs were spread.          
  She was laying on her back.   

100
00:04:25,498 --> 00:04:27,500
 [eerie music]                  

101
00:04:27,500 --> 00:04:32,605
  - [Suzanne] She had obvious   
 extensive trauma to the neck,  

102
00:04:32,905 --> 00:04:36,776
  where it appeared as though   
  her head was almost removed.  

103
00:04:36,776 --> 00:04:38,778
 [eerie music]                  

104
00:04:38,778 --> 00:04:40,680
The most unusual                
   injury on the body           

105
00:04:40,680 --> 00:04:44,183
  is that her entire            
   genital area was missing.    

106
00:04:44,183 --> 00:04:47,186
   [intriguing music]           

107
00:04:47,186 --> 00:04:49,689
  - [Mark] You could see there  
   was multiple stab wounds.    

108
00:04:49,689 --> 00:04:52,425
You could see that there        
was wounds to her hands         

109
00:04:52,425 --> 00:04:54,927
 that would most likely         
  be defensive wounds.          

110
00:04:54,927 --> 00:04:56,562
 [eerie music]                  

111
00:04:56,562 --> 00:04:59,699
 So it appeared by the          
  wounds that a knife was used  

112
00:04:59,699 --> 00:05:02,802
   for the stabbings and for    
   the cutting of her throat.   

113
00:05:02,802 --> 00:05:03,936
 [eerie music]                  

114
00:05:03,936 --> 00:05:07,573
   And we noted that the body   
   looked completely staged.    

115
00:05:07,573 --> 00:05:10,443
   [intriguing music]           

116
00:05:10,443 --> 00:05:13,446
   Well, at that point we're    
   thinking the perpetrator     

117
00:05:13,446 --> 00:05:17,216
   was purposely leaving the    
   body in a certain position   

118
00:05:17,216 --> 00:05:19,719
  to get some kind of           
 shock value out of it.         

119
00:05:19,719 --> 00:05:21,220
   [intriguing music]           

120
00:05:21,220 --> 00:05:24,724
  - The woman's right hand is   
  gesturing towards a painting  

121
00:05:24,724 --> 00:05:27,627
   of a blonde woman            
   on her back, nude,           

122
00:05:28,728 --> 00:05:31,564
   and her left hand,           
 with a crooked finger,         

123
00:05:31,564 --> 00:05:36,469
  is gesturing towards an open  
   copy of Sarasota Magazine,   

124
00:05:36,469 --> 00:05:39,238
 to a page of an article called 

125
00:05:39,238 --> 00:05:43,476
   "A Fine Madness," written    
  by Marcia Corbino,            

126
00:05:43,476 --> 00:05:45,745
   the queen of the             
  Sarasota art scene.           

127
00:05:45,745 --> 00:05:48,881
   [intriguing music]           

128
00:05:48,881 --> 00:05:51,117
 - [Mark] It was different than 
 any other crime scene          

129
00:05:51,117 --> 00:05:54,487
that we had encountered         
 in the past.                   

130
00:05:54,487 --> 00:05:56,489
This was something that         
 was straight out of,           

131
00:05:56,489 --> 00:05:58,725
  like, a horror movie almost,  

132
00:05:58,725 --> 00:06:02,028
   with the way the body was    
positioned, of a sexual nature, 

133
00:06:02,028 --> 00:06:03,896
 and how it had been mutilated  

134
00:06:03,896 --> 00:06:06,866
and probably meant to be        
that way by the killer.         

135
00:06:06,866 --> 00:06:08,735
 [eerie music]                  

136
00:06:08,735 --> 00:06:11,137
 - [Suzanne] Because of the way 
  the body was found,           

137
00:06:11,137 --> 00:06:13,506
  it was clear to us            
from the very beginning         

138
00:06:13,506 --> 00:06:15,875
  that our suspect was          
  most likely a male.           

139
00:06:15,875 --> 00:06:18,010
[dramatic string music]         

140
00:06:18,010 --> 00:06:21,147
  - [Alan] Detectives start to  
 track down Joyce's next of kin 

141
00:06:21,147 --> 00:06:23,516
   while the news that Joyce    
   Wishart has been murdered    

142
00:06:23,516 --> 00:06:25,151
  ripples through the           
   nearby galleries.            

143
00:06:25,151 --> 00:06:27,920
[dramatic string music]         

144
00:06:27,920 --> 00:06:29,889
   - [Mark] There was a crowd   
   developing                   

145
00:06:29,889 --> 00:06:31,190
and you start thinking,         

146
00:06:31,190 --> 00:06:33,893
 could the perpetrator          
   actually be in the crowd?    

147
00:06:33,893 --> 00:06:36,295
  They could be still on scene  
   watching what we're doing.   

148
00:06:36,295 --> 00:06:37,930
[dramatic string music]         

149
00:06:37,930 --> 00:06:39,766
 - [Alan] It doesn't take long  
   for Joyce's close friends    

150
00:06:39,766 --> 00:06:41,067
to learn of the tragedy.        

151
00:06:41,067 --> 00:06:43,536
[ominous music]                 

152
00:06:43,536 --> 00:06:48,307
   - When I first heard that    
   Joyce had been found dead,   

153
00:06:48,307 --> 00:06:52,211
it was complete and utter shock 

154
00:06:55,815 --> 00:06:57,316
   How can this be possible?"   

155
00:06:57,316 --> 00:06:58,651
[ominous music]                 

156
00:06:58,651 --> 00:07:01,921
 When we found out the grizzly  
   details, it was horrific     

157
00:07:01,921 --> 00:07:06,993
 to contemplate what must have  
   actually happened to her.    

158
00:07:07,660 --> 00:07:10,029
[ominous music]                 

159
00:07:12,665 --> 00:07:15,234
- [Michael] Joyce Wishart's kind
  of an amazing woman.          

160
00:07:15,234 --> 00:07:17,203
   She spent 20 years           
 being married.                 

161
00:07:17,203 --> 00:07:19,939
  She had a family in           
   Cincinnati, Ohio.            

162
00:07:19,939 --> 00:07:25,011
She left her husband and        
 decided he was a deadbeat dad. 

163
00:07:25,711 --> 00:07:27,079
  She went to school.           

164
00:07:27,079 --> 00:07:28,848
 She got an associate's         
  degree, a bachelor's degree,  

165
00:07:28,848 --> 00:07:32,084
   and a master's in            
   marketing and management.    

166
00:07:32,084 --> 00:07:34,353
  She said her dream            
  one day was to move           

167
00:07:34,353 --> 00:07:38,591
   to a warm weather climate    
  and operate an art gallery.   

168
00:07:38,591 --> 00:07:39,959
So that dream came true.        

169
00:07:39,959 --> 00:07:43,095
  [melancholic music]           
 [audience applauding]          

170
00:07:43,095 --> 00:07:48,134
  - [Linda] I first met Joyce   
  Wishart when I was exploring  

171
00:07:48,134 --> 00:07:51,237
  Sarasota as a place to move   
from upstate New York.          

172
00:07:51,237 --> 00:07:53,606
   She found out that           
  I had gotten the job          

173
00:07:53,606 --> 00:07:56,843
   as the marketing director    
 of the symphony here.          

174
00:07:56,843 --> 00:07:59,145
 She had a celebratory          
dinner for me.                  

175
00:07:59,145 --> 00:08:01,981
And I have a very vivid         
   memory of raising a glass    

176
00:08:01,981 --> 00:08:05,017
and celebrating the fact        
that I'd gotten the job.        

177
00:08:05,017 --> 00:08:07,620
  She was very                  
  friendly, very open.          

178
00:08:07,620 --> 00:08:10,723
 And one of the things          
 I admired about Joyce          

179
00:08:10,723 --> 00:08:14,393
is that she was really          
  able to transform her life.   

180
00:08:14,393 --> 00:08:16,863
  It was a real metamorphosis   

181
00:08:16,863 --> 00:08:19,632
and it was wonderful to         
be able to witness that.        

182
00:08:19,632 --> 00:08:22,268
   [intriguing music]           

183
00:08:22,268 --> 00:08:24,770
- [Alan] Joyce's journey        
   ended as she had lived it,   

184
00:08:24,770 --> 00:08:26,138
   surrounded by art            

185
00:08:26,138 --> 00:08:28,741
 and in the heart of a          
thriving arts community.        

186
00:08:28,741 --> 00:08:31,143
  And that is exactly           
  where investigators           

187
00:08:31,143 --> 00:08:33,179
   must look for her killer.    

188
00:08:33,179 --> 00:08:35,748
   - [Karen] We assumed from    
  the very beginning            

189
00:08:35,748 --> 00:08:39,051
 that this was a person         
  that knew our victim          

190
00:08:39,051 --> 00:08:42,421
   and had some plan            
   to eliminate her,            

191
00:08:42,421 --> 00:08:46,759
 some sort of personal          
  reason to kill her            

192
00:08:46,759 --> 00:08:49,295
   and kill her in the manner   
in which she was slain.         

193
00:08:49,295 --> 00:08:51,664
   [intriguing music]           

194
00:08:51,664 --> 00:08:54,133
 - [Alan] Joyce had no          
 employees to question.         

195
00:08:55,167 --> 00:08:57,036
  So, some detectives           
canvas the area                 

196
00:08:57,036 --> 00:08:59,171
 immediately around the gallery 

197
00:08:59,171 --> 00:09:01,807
 and others continue to         
 scour the crime scene          

198
00:09:01,807 --> 00:09:02,942
  for useful evidence.          

199
00:09:02,942 --> 00:09:04,010
   [intriguing music]           

200
00:09:04,010 --> 00:09:05,912
  - [Suzanne] And as we looked  
  around the gallery,           

201
00:09:05,912 --> 00:09:08,915
   we found several             
  things of interest.           

202
00:09:08,915 --> 00:09:12,351
   One was that the             
 front door was locked          

203
00:09:12,351 --> 00:09:16,923
 and the maintenance man could  
   not get in without a key.    

204
00:09:16,923 --> 00:09:21,827
  So that indicated to us that  
   the killer locked the door   

205
00:09:21,827 --> 00:09:22,929
 after he left.                 

206
00:09:22,929 --> 00:09:26,198
   [intriguing music]           

207
00:09:26,198 --> 00:09:29,201
  Fingerprints were collected   
   from all over the gallery    

208
00:09:29,201 --> 00:09:30,369
  by crime scene technicians.   

209
00:09:30,369 --> 00:09:31,971
   [intriguing music]           

210
00:09:31,971 --> 00:09:34,840
 And we tried to find matches.  

211
00:09:34,840 --> 00:09:36,342
 Who did these                  
fingerprints belong to?         

212
00:09:36,342 --> 00:09:37,810
   [intriguing music]           

213
00:09:37,810 --> 00:09:41,247
 The art behind Joyce's         
 head had blood on it.          

214
00:09:41,247 --> 00:09:45,484
   And some of the blood was    
clearly smudged blood,          

215
00:09:45,484 --> 00:09:47,820
  which would indicate          
that the killer                 

216
00:09:47,820 --> 00:09:51,257
 probably touched this          
 item after the murder          

217
00:09:51,257 --> 00:09:52,725
with blood on his hands.        

218
00:09:52,725 --> 00:09:53,759
   [intriguing music]           

219
00:09:53,759 --> 00:09:56,228
  - [Mark] Certainly our hope   
  is that the killer            

220
00:09:56,228 --> 00:09:58,731
 has left some of their         
   own blood behind,            

221
00:09:58,731 --> 00:10:00,366
   which will be DNA            
   that we could use            

222
00:10:00,366 --> 00:10:03,135
  in a profile to help          
  identify the killer.          

223
00:10:03,135 --> 00:10:05,137
   [intriguing music]           

224
00:10:05,137 --> 00:10:07,106
One of the things that          
   we'll do at a crime scene    

225
00:10:07,106 --> 00:10:10,409
   to find additional           
   blood is luminol,            

226
00:10:10,409 --> 00:10:12,111
which is going to pick up stuff 

227
00:10:12,111 --> 00:10:15,982
 that a perpetrator's going to  
  think they cleaned an area,   

228
00:10:15,982 --> 00:10:16,983
that they don't see it.         

229
00:10:16,983 --> 00:10:18,284
   [intriguing music]           

230
00:10:18,284 --> 00:10:20,419
  In the bathroom, it           
   lit up like neon.            

231
00:10:20,419 --> 00:10:22,888
  There was all kinds           
  of blood splattered           

232
00:10:22,888 --> 00:10:24,423
 that had been in there         
that had been wiped down        

233
00:10:24,423 --> 00:10:26,258
  but not completely.           

234
00:10:26,258 --> 00:10:27,393
 So there was a lot of cleanup  

235
00:10:27,393 --> 00:10:28,995
   that had gone on             
   in that bathroom,            

236
00:10:28,995 --> 00:10:32,398
   which, you know, certainly   
   would be the perpetrator.    

237
00:10:32,398 --> 00:10:34,533
 - [Alan] Detectives hold high  
 hopes that some of the blood   

238
00:10:34,533 --> 00:10:37,269
in the bathroom belongs         
  to the perpetrator,           

239
00:10:37,269 --> 00:10:40,306
but they'll have to wait        
   on DNA testing to be sure.   

240
00:10:40,306 --> 00:10:42,008
   [intriguing music]           

241
00:10:42,008 --> 00:10:44,143
   At the gallery next door,    
investigators discover          

242
00:10:44,143 --> 00:10:48,314
 a security camera and          
  eagerly review the footage.   

243
00:10:48,314 --> 00:10:51,050
- [Suzanne] We were able to get 
   one small piece of video     

244
00:10:51,050 --> 00:10:54,887
 that showed figures that would 
   go in and out of the door,   

245
00:10:54,887 --> 00:10:57,189
 but nothing was clear          
 enough to be useful.           

246
00:10:57,189 --> 00:10:58,891
   [intriguing music]           

247
00:10:58,891 --> 00:11:00,793
  - [Alan] The shadowy          
   images may not be helpful,   

248
00:11:00,793 --> 00:11:02,561
but thankfully there are        
 plenty of other leads          

249
00:11:02,561 --> 00:11:03,796
to investigate.                 

250
00:11:03,796 --> 00:11:05,431
   [intriguing music]           
[phone ringing]                 

251
00:11:05,431 --> 00:11:07,066
- [Mark] We were getting        
 numerous tips                  

252
00:11:07,066 --> 00:11:10,069
   of people calling in the     
  Sarasota Police Department.   

253
00:11:10,069 --> 00:11:13,806
We had some about an individual 
   on a bike, for instance,     

254
00:11:13,806 --> 00:11:15,041
   who had gone into            
  one of the galleries          

255
00:11:15,041 --> 00:11:16,442
   and caused a disturbance.    

256
00:11:16,442 --> 00:11:18,177
   [intriguing music]           

257
00:11:18,177 --> 00:11:22,581
 - [Michael] A thin white man,  
tall, sandy color hair,         

258
00:11:22,581 --> 00:11:25,951
who was belligerent and         
 was upsetting people.          

259
00:11:25,951 --> 00:11:27,319
  He'd gone inside one gallery  

260
00:11:27,319 --> 00:11:29,822
and had to be chased out        
   by the owner with a broom.   

261
00:11:29,822 --> 00:11:31,090
   [intriguing music]           

262
00:11:31,090 --> 00:11:33,359
 The reports of Bicycle Man are 
 similar enough to one another  

263
00:11:33,359 --> 00:11:36,962
 that police absolutely believe 
   they're true and accurate,   

264
00:11:36,962 --> 00:11:38,597
  but they don't know           
who the guy is.                 

265
00:11:38,597 --> 00:11:43,369
 [eerie music]                  

266
00:11:43,369 --> 00:11:46,472
 but investigators are watching 
 for him in case he reappears.  

267
00:11:46,472 --> 00:11:49,108
   [intriguing music]           

268
00:11:49,108 --> 00:11:51,977
Back at the crime scene         
   in the Provenance Gallery,   

269
00:11:51,977 --> 00:11:53,345
   detectives attempt           

270
00:11:53,345 --> 00:11:55,948
   to put the bizarre pieces    
of the puzzle together.         

271
00:11:55,948 --> 00:11:57,049
   [intriguing music]           

272
00:11:57,049 --> 00:11:58,951
 - [Mark] Is this killer trying 
  to send us a message          

273
00:11:58,951 --> 00:12:00,386
   by, "Look at this article"   

274
00:12:00,386 --> 00:12:04,490
   and this would have a clue   
   as to who that person was    

275
00:12:04,490 --> 00:12:06,525
or something along those lines? 

276
00:12:06,525 --> 00:12:08,627
   [intriguing music]           

277
00:12:08,627 --> 00:12:11,230
 - [Karen] It was important for 
   us to think about the fact   

278
00:12:11,230 --> 00:12:13,632
  that this took place          
   in an art gallery,           

279
00:12:13,632 --> 00:12:16,268
   that her life was            
   surrounded by art.           

280
00:12:16,268 --> 00:12:20,973
  There were multiple pictures  
  surrounding the body          

281
00:12:20,973 --> 00:12:29,148
  and we thought, "Is there a   
 clue in any of these paintings 

282
00:12:29,148 --> 00:12:31,650
  that give us a clue           
about why this happened,        

283
00:12:31,650 --> 00:12:33,652
how it happened,                
   and who did this?"           

284
00:12:33,652 --> 00:12:35,254
   [intriguing music]           

285
00:12:35,254 --> 00:12:36,622
- [Suzanne] It did seem that the
   killer was making            

286
00:12:36,622 --> 00:12:39,258
some statement.                 

287
00:12:39,258 --> 00:12:42,661
 It wasn't obvious what         
   the statement was.           

288
00:12:42,661 --> 00:12:44,430
   [intriguing music]           

289
00:12:44,430 --> 00:12:46,132
 - [Alan] Coming up...          

290
00:12:46,132 --> 00:12:49,568
 - [Linda] It made us all very  
nervous and very scared         

291
00:12:49,568 --> 00:12:53,272
   that there could actually    
 be a killer among us.          

292
00:12:53,272 --> 00:12:56,275
- [Suzanne] His fingerprints are
 all over the gallery,          

293
00:12:56,275 --> 00:12:58,310
  and his magazine is           
part of the crime scene.        

294
00:12:58,310 --> 00:13:02,414
 - They said, "Ms. Wishart was  
 found holding the magazine."   

295
00:13:02,414 --> 00:13:05,251
[dramatic music]                

296
00:13:08,454 --> 00:13:08,487
   [i                           

297
00:13:08,487 --> 00:13:08,521
   [int                         

298
00:13:08,521 --> 00:13:08,554
   [intri                       

299
00:13:08,554 --> 00:13:08,587
   [intrigu                     

300
00:13:08,587 --> 00:13:08,621
   [intriguin                   

301
00:13:08,621 --> 00:13:08,654
   [intriguing                  

302
00:13:08,654 --> 00:13:08,687
   [intriguing mu               

303
00:13:08,687 --> 00:13:08,721
   [intriguing musi             

304
00:13:08,721 --> 00:13:10,322
   [intriguing music]           

305
00:13:15,461 --> 00:13:16,862
 - [Alan] It's been eight hours 

306
00:13:16,862 --> 00:13:19,031
 since Joyce Wishart's          
   brutalized body was found    

307
00:13:19,031 --> 00:13:21,000
  in her Sarasota art gallery.  

308
00:13:21,000 --> 00:13:22,635
   [intriguing music]           

309
00:13:22,635 --> 00:13:25,471
   At the station, detectives   
 have finally been able to find 

310
00:13:25,471 --> 00:13:28,374
   and notify Joyce's           
adult children.                 

311
00:13:28,374 --> 00:13:29,742
A somber responsibility.        

312
00:13:29,742 --> 00:13:30,676
   [intriguing music]           

313
00:13:30,676 --> 00:13:32,778
 - [Mark] Ms. Wishart had four  
   children,                    

314
00:13:32,778 --> 00:13:34,747
two of which she                
   was estranged with           

315
00:13:34,747 --> 00:13:36,649
  and two of which she          
  was in contact with.          

316
00:13:36,649 --> 00:13:38,150
   [intriguing music]           

317
00:13:38,150 --> 00:13:40,619
  - [Suzanne] And we spoke to   
  her daughter first            

318
00:13:40,619 --> 00:13:44,023
 and had to notify her,         
obviously, of what had happened.

319
00:13:44,023 --> 00:13:47,893
 We also spoke to her son, who  
 was very distraught as well,   

320
00:13:47,893 --> 00:13:49,795
  and he hadn't seen            
 her in several weeks.          

321
00:13:49,795 --> 00:13:51,397
   [intriguing music]           

322
00:13:51,397 --> 00:13:54,900
- So when her family got        
the news of the murder,         

323
00:13:54,900 --> 00:13:56,669
   shocked doesn't cover it.    

324
00:13:56,669 --> 00:13:58,170
They were completely devastated.

325
00:13:58,170 --> 00:14:00,806
   [intriguing music]           

326
00:14:00,806 --> 00:14:03,509
  - [Alan] When asked if they   
  had any idea who did this,    

327
00:14:03,509 --> 00:14:06,645
Joyce's grieving family         
  shares an unsettling detail.  

328
00:14:06,645 --> 00:14:09,648
   [intriguing music]           

329
00:14:09,648 --> 00:14:10,950
 - [Mark] We did learn from the 
children                        

330
00:14:10,950 --> 00:14:15,187
that the ex-husband had         
   some issues with drinking    

331
00:14:15,187 --> 00:14:17,189
 and had been                   
 volatile in the past.          

332
00:14:17,189 --> 00:14:18,791
   [intriguing music]           

333
00:14:18,791 --> 00:14:21,560
  - [Suzanne] He had allegedly  
  been violent to her           

334
00:14:21,560 --> 00:14:24,697
 and allegedly stabbed          
her in the legs before.         

335
00:14:24,697 --> 00:14:26,932
   [intriguing music]           

336
00:14:26,932 --> 00:14:28,701
 - [Mark] It certainly          
  raised our concern            

337
00:14:28,701 --> 00:14:30,569
  that if he had been           
  abusive in the past,          

338
00:14:30,569 --> 00:14:33,672
 that he could be somebody who  
  had been be violent again.    

339
00:14:33,672 --> 00:14:35,441
 So, certainly he was           
 a person of interest.          

340
00:14:35,441 --> 00:14:37,543
[ominous music]                 

341
00:14:37,543 --> 00:14:39,445
   - [Alan] But when            
 they find Joyce's ex,          

342
00:14:39,445 --> 00:14:41,080
   he's not what they expect.   

343
00:14:41,080 --> 00:14:42,948
[ominous music]                 

344
00:14:42,948 --> 00:14:45,818
  - [Mark] The ex-husband was   
 several states away,           

345
00:14:45,818 --> 00:14:46,986
was in a frail condition        

346
00:14:46,986 --> 00:14:49,722
  and not able to be a          
 suspect in this crime.         

347
00:14:49,722 --> 00:14:52,825
[ominous music]                 

348
00:14:52,825 --> 00:14:54,860
   - [Alan] With the            
  ex-husband out of suspicion,  

349
00:14:54,860 --> 00:14:58,130
 investigators now turned back  
  to the very arts community    

350
00:14:58,130 --> 00:15:01,233
 that Joyce had thrived         
   in for many years.           

351
00:15:01,233 --> 00:15:03,836
  - [Suzanne] Sarasota Police   
   Department wanted to know    

352
00:15:03,836 --> 00:15:05,871
  what members of the           
 art community had been         

353
00:15:05,871 --> 00:15:09,742
 in and out of Joyce's gallery  
   within the previous week.    

354
00:15:09,742 --> 00:15:11,710
[dramatic string music]         

355
00:15:11,710 --> 00:15:15,981
   So they were using various   
   things to compile a list.    

356
00:15:15,981 --> 00:15:20,619
  Her phone messages that we    
found on her answering machine, 

357
00:15:20,619 --> 00:15:21,854
 her appointment book.          

358
00:15:21,854 --> 00:15:23,122
[dramatic string music]         

359
00:15:23,122 --> 00:15:25,257
   [intriguing music]           

360
00:15:25,257 --> 00:15:27,860
 - [Mark] At that time, we were 
  exploring different theories  

361
00:15:27,860 --> 00:15:29,862
as to what had occurred,        

362
00:15:29,862 --> 00:15:33,232
   one of which would be she    
 had art there on consignment.  

363
00:15:34,266 --> 00:15:37,636
  Could this be an artist or    
somebody that's upset with her? 

364
00:15:37,636 --> 00:15:39,038
Somebody that was trying        
   to sell art to her           

365
00:15:39,038 --> 00:15:40,639
that was upset with her?        

366
00:15:40,639 --> 00:15:42,041
   [intriguing music]           

367
00:15:42,041 --> 00:15:44,143
 - [Suzanne] Investigators also 
  spoke to the people           

368
00:15:44,143 --> 00:15:46,512
that were right in that complex,

369
00:15:46,512 --> 00:15:51,583
   other art gallery owners,    
   to see what they had seen,   

370
00:15:52,151 --> 00:15:53,519
 if they knew anything          

371
00:15:53,519 --> 00:15:55,888
  or if there were any          
   suspicious people.           

372
00:15:55,888 --> 00:15:57,623
   [intriguing music]           

373
00:15:57,623 --> 00:16:01,293
 - [Alan] Despite the extensive 
  canvas, no new leads emerge.  

374
00:16:01,293 --> 00:16:03,796
   However, evidence gathered   
   at the crime scene           

375
00:16:03,796 --> 00:16:07,166
 is starting to paint a         
 clearer picture of the murder. 

376
00:16:07,166 --> 00:16:11,170
   [intriguing music]           

377
00:16:11,170 --> 00:16:12,671
 as possible evidence.          

378
00:16:12,671 --> 00:16:14,173
They took that to the crime lab 

379
00:16:14,173 --> 00:16:16,909
   and then were able           
   to do an analysis,           

380
00:16:16,909 --> 00:16:19,311
and the analysis showed         
   that the computer            

381
00:16:19,311 --> 00:16:24,516
 had been logged off at         
 4:52 PM, Friday 16th,          

382
00:16:25,084 --> 00:16:26,785
  and she did not log back in.  

383
00:16:26,785 --> 00:16:31,090
   [intriguing music]           

384
00:16:31,090 --> 00:16:34,560
Friday, that whoever killed her 
must have done it very quickly  

385
00:16:34,560 --> 00:16:36,328
   after she logged             
  off of the computer           

386
00:16:36,328 --> 00:16:39,331
  because she would've closed   
  the gallery at five o'clock.  

387
00:16:39,331 --> 00:16:40,833
   [intriguing music]           

388
00:16:40,833 --> 00:16:43,302
  - We also contacted           
  her alarm company.            

389
00:16:44,570 --> 00:16:47,840
   We were able to establish    
 that she typically logged off  

390
00:16:47,840 --> 00:16:49,808
  each day at 5:00 PM           

391
00:16:49,808 --> 00:16:51,677
  and she had not done          
  that on that Friday.          

392
00:16:51,677 --> 00:16:53,579
   [intriguing music]           

393
00:16:53,579 --> 00:16:55,814
Once we determined that         
   Ms. Wishart had logged off   

394
00:16:55,814 --> 00:17:00,686
   at 4:51 PM, that the alarm   
  had not been set at 5:00 PM,  

395
00:17:00,686 --> 00:17:02,688
this gave us a timeframe        
 as to when we believe          

396
00:17:02,688 --> 00:17:04,223
   the homicide had occurred.   

397
00:17:04,223 --> 00:17:06,959
   [intriguing music]           

398
00:17:06,959 --> 00:17:09,828
- [Suzanne] It was very possible
 that whoever did this          

399
00:17:09,828 --> 00:17:12,598
 was someone close to           
 her or the community,          

400
00:17:12,598 --> 00:17:14,366
   because they would           
   have the knowledge           

401
00:17:14,366 --> 00:17:16,235
  of when the gallery closed.   

402
00:17:16,235 --> 00:17:19,738
   [intriguing music]           

403
00:17:19,738 --> 00:17:22,708
[dramatic string music]         

404
00:17:22,708 --> 00:17:25,110
 - [Alan] And then the          
  crime lab results come back   

405
00:17:25,110 --> 00:17:26,979
   with a fingerprint match.    

406
00:17:26,979 --> 00:17:29,014
  - [Mark] The hit that we did  
get on the fingerprints         

407
00:17:29,014 --> 00:17:31,116
   was a man by the             
  name of Jimmy Dean.           

408
00:17:31,116 --> 00:17:32,718
[dramatic string music]         

409
00:17:32,718 --> 00:17:35,120
   - [Alan] Jimmy Dean is a     
  prominent local businessman   

410
00:17:35,120 --> 00:17:37,289
whose prints were in the system 
  because he had volunteered    

411
00:17:37,289 --> 00:17:39,992
with a youth group in the city. 

412
00:17:39,992 --> 00:17:41,627
  And that's not all.           

413
00:17:41,627 --> 00:17:43,028
- [Suzanne] And that was        
  interesting                   

414
00:17:43,028 --> 00:17:45,130
  because he was the publisher  
 of Sarasota Magazine,          

415
00:17:45,130 --> 00:17:48,033
   and the magazine that was    
  laying next to Joyce's body   

416
00:17:48,033 --> 00:17:50,736
   was the Sarasota Magazine    
 and had blood on it.           

417
00:17:50,736 --> 00:17:53,038
[dramatic string music]         

418
00:17:53,038 --> 00:17:54,640
  We didn't know what           
  the relationship was          

419
00:17:54,640 --> 00:17:57,009
   and it was something that    
   needed to be investigated.   

420
00:17:57,009 --> 00:18:04,149
[dramatic string music]         

421
00:18:10,089 --> 00:18:10,122
   [i                           

422
00:18:10,122 --> 00:18:10,155
   [int                         

423
00:18:10,155 --> 00:18:10,189
   [intri                       

424
00:18:10,189 --> 00:18:10,222
   [intrigu                     

425
00:18:10,222 --> 00:18:10,255
   [intriguin                   

426
00:18:10,255 --> 00:18:10,289
   [intriguing                  

427
00:18:10,289 --> 00:18:10,322
   [intriguing mu               

428
00:18:10,322 --> 00:18:10,355
   [intriguing musi             

429
00:18:10,355 --> 00:18:11,657
   [intriguing music]           

430
00:18:18,263 --> 00:18:20,165
  - [Alan] Investigators have   
  matched fingerprints found    

431
00:18:20,165 --> 00:18:22,534
 at the scene of Joyce          
   Wishart's murder             

432
00:18:22,534 --> 00:18:26,171
   to those of the prominent    
publisher of Sarasota Magazine, 

433
00:18:26,171 --> 00:18:27,039
  Jimmy Dean.                   

434
00:18:27,039 --> 00:18:29,808
   [intriguing music]           

435
00:18:29,808 --> 00:18:32,544
 - His fingerprints are         
  all over the gallery          

436
00:18:32,544 --> 00:18:34,813
  and his magazine is           
part of the crime scene.        

437
00:18:34,813 --> 00:18:36,682
   [intriguing music]           

438
00:18:36,682 --> 00:18:38,550
   - [Alan] He's brought into   
  the station for questioning.  

439
00:18:38,550 --> 00:18:41,320
   [intriguing music]           

440
00:18:41,320 --> 00:18:43,689
- [Suzanne] Jimmy Dean said that
   he was friends with Joyce    

441
00:18:43,689 --> 00:18:46,291
   and that he would            
   go by her gallery            

442
00:18:46,291 --> 00:18:47,559
   once every couple of weeks   

443
00:18:47,559 --> 00:18:50,162
  to see if she wanted          
  ads in his magazine.          

444
00:18:50,162 --> 00:18:52,064
   [intriguing music]           

445
00:18:52,064 --> 00:18:53,332
- We talked to him about        

446
00:18:53,332 --> 00:18:56,435
  when he was last at           
the Provenance Gallery.         

447
00:18:56,435 --> 00:18:58,570
He advised he was there         
the day of the murder.          

448
00:18:58,570 --> 00:19:00,172
   [intriguing music]           

449
00:19:00,172 --> 00:19:01,607
   But he said that             
wasn't unusual for him.         

450
00:19:01,607 --> 00:19:03,709
[dramatic string music]         

451
00:19:03,709 --> 00:19:05,477
  - [Alan] Detectives           
then present Jimmy Dean         

452
00:19:05,477 --> 00:19:07,613
 with the evidence that places  
him at the crime scene.         

453
00:19:07,613 --> 00:19:08,714
   [intriguing music]           

454
00:19:08,714 --> 00:19:10,716
- I had no idea                 
  what this was about.          

455
00:19:10,716 --> 00:19:13,185
   I, you know, had no idea.    

456
00:19:13,185 --> 00:19:19,324
   [intriguing music]           

457
00:19:20,325 --> 00:19:22,628
 open to this page and          
 she was touching it."          

458
00:19:22,628 --> 00:19:24,196
[dramatic string music]         

459
00:19:24,196 --> 00:19:27,866
  They said, "We found          
   your fingerprints            

460
00:19:27,866 --> 00:19:30,235
 all over her gallery."         

461
00:19:30,235 --> 00:19:32,771
I heard that and I must         
have just turned white.         

462
00:19:32,771 --> 00:19:34,873
   [intriguing music]           

463
00:19:34,873 --> 00:19:36,775
   "And that's what leads us    

464
00:19:36,775 --> 00:19:39,111
to you here this                
   morning, Mr. Dean.           

465
00:19:39,111 --> 00:19:40,612
Sounds a little fishy."         

466
00:19:40,612 --> 00:19:42,214
   [intriguing music]           

467
00:19:42,214 --> 00:19:46,785
   They then proceed to ask     
   me a series of questions.    

468
00:19:46,785 --> 00:19:48,253
   [intriguing music]           

469
00:19:48,253 --> 00:19:51,657
  The salient question          
that stood out,                 

470
00:19:51,657 --> 00:19:55,360
  was I in a romantic           
 relationship with her?         

471
00:19:55,360 --> 00:19:56,628
   [intriguing music]           

472
00:19:56,628 --> 00:19:58,897
   And I was married,           
   happily married with kids,   

473
00:19:58,897 --> 00:20:01,500
and, you know, no, I...         

474
00:20:01,500 --> 00:20:02,267
 We're friends.                 

475
00:20:02,267 --> 00:20:05,671
   [intriguing music]           

476
00:20:05,671 --> 00:20:07,139
  - [Alan] Before they          
   leave Jimmy Dean,            

477
00:20:07,139 --> 00:20:10,275
   investigators ask            
  him for a DNA swab.           

478
00:20:10,275 --> 00:20:13,779
It could link him to the        
 murder or prove his innocence. 

479
00:20:13,779 --> 00:20:15,914
   [intriguing music]           

480
00:20:15,914 --> 00:20:18,383
- [Suzanne] When law enforcement
   asked for his DNA sample,    

481
00:20:18,383 --> 00:20:19,818
   he freely gave it.           

482
00:20:19,818 --> 00:20:21,687
   [intriguing music]           

483
00:20:21,687 --> 00:20:24,790
 - [Alan] Detectives hang their 
   hopes on Jimmy Dean's DNA    

484
00:20:24,790 --> 00:20:27,659
  matching the bathroom blood   
  samples at the crime scene.   

485
00:20:27,659 --> 00:20:33,932
   [intriguing music]           

486
00:20:33,932 --> 00:20:36,535
   - [Mark] We did get a DNA    
profile                         

487
00:20:36,535 --> 00:20:38,670
from Florida Department         
  of Law Enforcement,           

488
00:20:38,670 --> 00:20:41,940
a male subject whose DNA        
  was left at the crime scene.  

489
00:20:41,940 --> 00:20:43,709
   [intriguing music]           

490
00:20:43,709 --> 00:20:44,710
 - [Suzanne] And they were able 
  to eliminate                  

491
00:20:44,710 --> 00:20:47,412
Jimmy Dean as a suspect         

492
00:20:47,412 --> 00:20:49,548
  because his DNA did           
 not match the profile          

493
00:20:49,548 --> 00:20:50,816
 found in the bathroom.         

494
00:20:50,816 --> 00:20:54,319
[dramatic string music]         

495
00:20:54,319 --> 00:20:56,421
 - [Jimmy] She was a very good  
woman.                          

496
00:20:56,421 --> 00:20:59,558
What happened to her did        
 not deserve to happen.         

497
00:20:59,558 --> 00:21:01,960
  Who could have done           
 such a horrible thing?         

498
00:21:01,960 --> 00:21:05,597
 [dramatic piano music]         

499
00:21:05,597 --> 00:21:07,599
- [Alan] Jimmy Dean is relieved 
  to be cleared of suspicion    

500
00:21:07,599 --> 00:21:10,202
  but troubled by his           
   connection to the murder.    

501
00:21:10,202 --> 00:21:12,571
[dramatic piano                 
   and string music]            

502
00:21:12,571 --> 00:21:14,940
  - [Jimmy] The questions that  
 went through our heads         

503
00:21:14,940 --> 00:21:17,342
  at the magazine was,          

504
00:21:17,342 --> 00:21:20,746
  "Why is our magazine          
  so involved in this murder?"  

505
00:21:20,746 --> 00:21:22,314
[dramatic piano                 
   and string music]            

506
00:21:22,314 --> 00:21:24,483
As we were going through        
   our mental rolodex           

507
00:21:24,483 --> 00:21:26,852
 of possible suspects,          

508
00:21:26,852 --> 00:21:30,489
  we couldn't come up           
  with any solid lead,          

509
00:21:30,489 --> 00:21:34,459
   and who could we possibly    
know that is that evil?         

510
00:21:34,459 --> 00:21:37,663
 [dramatic piano music]         

511
00:21:40,999 --> 00:21:44,369
   - [Linda] All of the arts    
community was on edge after this

512
00:21:44,369 --> 00:21:47,773
   murder because this person   
  had not been found.           

513
00:21:47,773 --> 00:21:50,876
  This person could still be    
 living in the same community.  

514
00:21:50,876 --> 00:21:53,845
   [intriguing music]           

515
00:21:54,946 --> 00:21:59,017
- [Jimmy] The arts community in 
 general went into panic mode.  

516
00:21:59,017 --> 00:22:01,920
  They did not stay open late.  

517
00:22:01,920 --> 00:22:03,889
Many of them closed before dark.

518
00:22:03,889 --> 00:22:06,758
Many of them kept their         
 doors locked all day.          

519
00:22:06,758 --> 00:22:08,360
   [intriguing music]           

520
00:22:08,360 --> 00:22:10,495
 - [Linda] If there's somebody  
   here who was walking the     

521
00:22:10,495 --> 00:22:15,367
 streets, who was eating at the 
 local diner, who was riding a  

522
00:22:15,367 --> 00:22:18,770
bicycle, walking the sidewalks, 
   who could it be?             

523
00:22:18,770 --> 00:22:22,407
  It made us all very           
nervous and very scared         

524
00:22:22,407 --> 00:22:27,045
   that there could actually    
 be a killer among us           

525
00:22:27,045 --> 00:22:29,281
  and we would never know it.   

526
00:22:29,281 --> 00:22:30,515
   [intriguing music]           

527
00:22:30,515 --> 00:22:32,517
[dramatic piano                 
   and string music]            

528
00:22:32,517 --> 00:22:35,287
   - [Alan] It's been a month   
  since Joyce's murder          

529
00:22:35,287 --> 00:22:38,523
and the intense media attention 
is finally paying off.          

530
00:22:38,523 --> 00:22:39,791
[dramatic piano                 
   and string music]            

531
00:22:39,791 --> 00:22:41,526
 - [Mark] We get a tip          
  from a man who says           

532
00:22:41,526 --> 00:22:44,062
  he thinks he saw the killer   
the day of the murder.          

533
00:22:44,062 --> 00:22:46,665
   [intriguing music]           

534
00:22:46,665 --> 00:22:49,534
- [Suzanne] It was someone that 
frequented the gallery.         

535
00:22:49,534 --> 00:22:51,970
   On the day of the murder,    
  he was outside the gallery.   

536
00:22:51,970 --> 00:22:54,573
  He wanted to speak to Joyce.  

537
00:22:54,573 --> 00:22:57,309
  But he didn't go in because   
  he saw her speaking to a man  

538
00:22:57,309 --> 00:22:58,543
  in a leather jacket.          

539
00:22:59,478 --> 00:23:01,546
 And we wondered, could         
  this be our killer?           

540
00:23:01,546 --> 00:23:04,549
   [intriguing music]           

541
00:23:10,255 --> 00:23:10,288
[o                              

542
00:23:10,288 --> 00:23:10,322
[omi                            

543
00:23:10,322 --> 00:23:10,355
[omino                          

544
00:23:10,355 --> 00:23:10,389
[ominous                        

545
00:23:10,389 --> 00:23:10,422
[ominous m                      

546
00:23:10,422 --> 00:23:10,455
[ominous mus                    

547
00:23:10,455 --> 00:23:10,489
[ominous music                  

548
00:23:10,489 --> 00:23:11,990
[ominous music]                 

549
00:23:17,429 --> 00:23:19,564
 - [Alan] As the investigations 
  into Joyce Wishart's murder   

550
00:23:19,564 --> 00:23:22,300
stretches into its second month,

551
00:23:22,300 --> 00:23:25,570
 a man named Henry Gabo         
  calls the tip line.           

552
00:23:25,570 --> 00:23:28,507
   [intriguing music]           

553
00:23:29,241 --> 00:23:31,176
  - [Mark] In speaking to Mr.   
 Gabo,                          

554
00:23:31,176 --> 00:23:34,045
 he gave a description          
   of a male subject            

555
00:23:34,045 --> 00:23:36,081
 that had been in the gallery.  

556
00:23:36,081 --> 00:23:37,449
   [intriguing music]           

557
00:23:37,449 --> 00:23:40,185
 Mr. Gabo described the         
  individual as a male          

558
00:23:40,185 --> 00:23:43,221
 with a leather jacket          
with slicked-back hair.         

559
00:23:43,221 --> 00:23:46,591
 Although he could not          
   provide very much detail,    

560
00:23:46,591 --> 00:23:50,061
Mr. Gobo believed he was        
in the gallery at 4:45.         

561
00:23:50,061 --> 00:23:52,330
   [intriguing music]           

562
00:23:52,330 --> 00:23:54,499
 One of the things that         
 was interesting to us          

563
00:23:54,499 --> 00:23:57,969
 was that we know that          
  the crime occurred            

564
00:23:57,969 --> 00:24:00,105
   somewhere in between 4:51    

565
00:24:00,105 --> 00:24:03,074
and around five                 
 o'clock that evening,          

566
00:24:03,074 --> 00:24:05,610
that there was not much         
  time for the killer           

567
00:24:05,610 --> 00:24:08,213
   to actually enter            
  without being seen.           

568
00:24:08,213 --> 00:24:11,082
   [intriguing music]           

569
00:24:11,082 --> 00:24:14,519
 So we believe that the killer  
was watching the scene,         

570
00:24:14,519 --> 00:24:18,123
casing it, and waiting          
   for his exact opportunity    

571
00:24:18,123 --> 00:24:20,992
   to get inside the gallery    
with no one else there.         

572
00:24:20,992 --> 00:24:23,462
 [eerie music]                  

573
00:24:27,399 --> 00:24:29,501
   - [Alan] Mr. Gabo agrees     
   to look at a photo lineup    

574
00:24:29,501 --> 00:24:31,002
 of potential suspects.         

575
00:24:31,002 --> 00:24:32,637
 [eerie music]                  

576
00:24:32,637 --> 00:24:35,540
 - Ultimately, he was unable to 
 pick anyone out of the lineup  

577
00:24:35,540 --> 00:24:38,543
 because he didn't get a clear  
   view of this individual.     

578
00:24:38,543 --> 00:24:41,246
 He only got a partial          
   side view of him             

579
00:24:41,246 --> 00:24:43,648
  and was not able to           
make an identification.         

580
00:24:43,648 --> 00:24:45,984
 [eerie music]                  

581
00:24:45,984 --> 00:24:48,520
   [intriguing music]           

582
00:24:48,520 --> 00:24:50,255
 - [Karen] It was very          
 frustrating.                   

583
00:24:50,255 --> 00:24:53,158
   We had many, many            
 brainstorming sessions         

584
00:24:53,158 --> 00:24:54,392
  trying to figure out          

585
00:24:54,392 --> 00:24:58,029
  what in God's name            
happened to this woman,         

586
00:24:58,029 --> 00:25:00,398
who did it, and why they did it.

587
00:25:00,398 --> 00:25:03,301
Why did such a horrible         
   crime like this take place   

588
00:25:03,301 --> 00:25:06,271
  in broad daylight in          
   downtown Sarasota?           

589
00:25:06,271 --> 00:25:09,174
 [eerie music]                  

590
00:25:09,174 --> 00:25:11,042
 - [Alan] Investigators         
   are still holding out hope   

591
00:25:11,042 --> 00:25:14,012
   that DNA gathered            
   at the crime scene           

592
00:25:14,012 --> 00:25:15,914
   will help find the killer.   

593
00:25:15,914 --> 00:25:17,182
   [intriguing music]           

594
00:25:17,182 --> 00:25:20,285
 - [Suzanne] It was imperative  
that we got as many DNA profiles

595
00:25:20,285 --> 00:25:24,189
 as we could and try and match  
  it to this unknown profile.   

596
00:25:24,189 --> 00:25:26,157
   [intriguing music]           

597
00:25:26,157 --> 00:25:28,927
They went to Joyce's associates.

598
00:25:28,927 --> 00:25:31,029
  They went to people           
that worked with Joyce.         

599
00:25:31,029 --> 00:25:36,034
 They went to her friends, they 
 went to anyone that knew her.  

600
00:25:36,034 --> 00:25:40,038
   They even started swabbing   
  complete strangers.           

601
00:25:40,038 --> 00:25:44,075
 They took probably 100         
 different DNA profiles         

602
00:25:44,075 --> 00:25:45,577
  from people in the community  

603
00:25:45,577 --> 00:25:47,312
  just to see if they           
   could get a match            

604
00:25:47,312 --> 00:25:48,713
to this unknown profile.        

605
00:25:48,713 --> 00:25:49,714
   [intriguing music]           

606
00:25:49,714 --> 00:25:51,049
- [Mark] We knew we did have the
  DNA,                          

607
00:25:51,049 --> 00:25:53,451
we just did not                 
   have a DNA match.            

608
00:25:53,451 --> 00:25:56,454
   [intriguing music]           

609
00:25:57,589 --> 00:26:00,725
  The fact that we did          
   not have a DNA hit           

610
00:26:00,725 --> 00:26:03,461
  would mean either the person  

611
00:26:03,461 --> 00:26:06,197
who committed the crime         
has never been arrested         

612
00:26:06,197 --> 00:26:09,200
and never was compelled         
 to give a DNA sample.          

613
00:26:09,200 --> 00:26:11,202
   So, that was what            
   we're looking at,            

614
00:26:11,202 --> 00:26:12,604
   that there's a possibility   

615
00:26:12,604 --> 00:26:14,973
  that maybe we would           
  never get a DNA hit.          

616
00:26:14,973 --> 00:26:18,209
- [Karen] And yet when we looked
  at the crime itself,          

617
00:26:18,209 --> 00:26:22,213
 it seemed that only a          
person that knew Joyce,         

618
00:26:22,213 --> 00:26:24,215
 that disliked her so intensely 

619
00:26:24,215 --> 00:26:27,252
   could have committed this    
kind of personal crime.         

620
00:26:27,252 --> 00:26:28,186
   [intriguing music]           

621
00:26:28,186 --> 00:26:30,488
- [Linda] All of us were pretty 
   nervous,                     

622
00:26:30,488 --> 00:26:31,990
because we felt                 
  that the perpetrator          

623
00:26:31,990 --> 00:26:34,092
could still be in the community.

624
00:26:34,092 --> 00:26:37,028
   [intriguing music]           

625
00:26:41,499 --> 00:26:44,402
- [Alan] Despite                
 investigators' intense effort, 

626
00:26:44,402 --> 00:26:46,638
   leads in the case            
   begin to run dry.            

627
00:26:46,638 --> 00:26:49,407
[ominous music]                 

628
00:26:49,407 --> 00:26:51,276
  - [Mark] Six months goes by   

629
00:26:51,276 --> 00:26:53,511
  doing pretty much everything  
 we could possibly do.          

630
00:26:53,511 --> 00:26:59,250
[ominous music]                 

631
00:26:59,250 --> 00:27:00,685
   - [Alan] With no             
  breaks in the case,           

632
00:27:00,685 --> 00:27:04,389
the tension in Sarasota         
  is as high as ever.           

633
00:27:04,389 --> 00:27:08,660
  - You could not go anywhere   
without people wanting to know, 

634
00:27:08,660 --> 00:27:12,130
"Have you heard anything        
   else?" "What do you know?"   

635
00:27:12,130 --> 00:27:13,398
[ominous music]                 

636
00:27:13,398 --> 00:27:16,668
 Everyone was walking           
on eggshells with fear.         

637
00:27:16,668 --> 00:27:18,570
   [intriguing music]           

638
00:27:18,570 --> 00:27:23,675
  - So there was, generally, I  
 would say, a level of anxiety, 

639
00:27:24,709 --> 00:27:26,444
particularly in                 
   the downtown area,           

640
00:27:26,444 --> 00:27:30,181
 that this person could         
   be out and about.            

641
00:27:30,181 --> 00:27:32,550
   [intriguing music]           

642
00:27:32,550 --> 00:27:35,687
   And who knows what           
   else he might do.            

643
00:27:35,687 --> 00:27:38,657
   [intriguing music]           

644
00:27:40,058 --> 00:27:42,327
 - [Alan] And then almost seven 
 months                         

645
00:27:42,327 --> 00:27:45,296
 after Joyce Wishart's          
brutal murder,                  

646
00:27:45,296 --> 00:27:48,166
  a lead comes in from          
   1,000 miles away.            

647
00:27:48,166 --> 00:27:50,568
 [eerie music]                  

648
00:27:52,437 --> 00:27:55,473
   - [Mark] In July of 2004,    

649
00:27:55,473 --> 00:28:02,080
 we get a DNA hit on a subject  
  who was in Houston, Texas.    

650
00:28:02,080 --> 00:28:03,081
 [eerie music]                  

651
00:28:03,081 --> 00:28:04,449
 - [Suzanne] We were ecstatic.  

652
00:28:04,449 --> 00:28:05,850
   [intriguing music]           

653
00:28:05,850 --> 00:28:07,318
 - [Mark] It was very exciting  

654
00:28:07,318 --> 00:28:09,587
that we've been working         
 so hard on this case           

655
00:28:09,587 --> 00:28:12,357
and now we actually had         
 a match on a suspect.          

656
00:28:12,357 --> 00:28:13,591
   [intriguing music]           

657
00:28:13,591 --> 00:28:17,495
- [Suzanne] When we looked into 
 who the profile belonged to,   

658
00:28:17,495 --> 00:28:20,865
it was a bit perplexing         
because he wasn't a name        

659
00:28:20,865 --> 00:28:26,137
  that came up on any of the    
  lists, any of the canvases.   

660
00:28:28,606 --> 00:28:29,708
   [intriguing music]           

661
00:28:29,708 --> 00:28:31,509
- [Mark] The DNA match actually 
  came from a subject           

662
00:28:31,509 --> 00:28:33,878
 by the name of                 
  Elton Brutus Murphy.          

663
00:28:33,878 --> 00:28:36,247
   [intriguing music]           

664
00:28:36,247 --> 00:28:38,383
- [Suzanne] He had been arrested
 in Texas for burglary          

665
00:28:38,383 --> 00:28:40,351
  and he was sitting in jail.   

666
00:28:40,351 --> 00:28:42,220
We needed to tie                
him to Sarasota,                

667
00:28:42,220 --> 00:28:44,789
 and we needed to show          
  that he was present           

668
00:28:44,789 --> 00:28:47,759
  during the time that          
  Joyce was murdered.           

669
00:28:47,759 --> 00:28:50,762
   [intriguing music]           

670
00:28:54,766 --> 00:28:54,799
[d                              

671
00:28:54,799 --> 00:28:54,833
[dra                            

672
00:28:54,833 --> 00:28:54,866
[drama                          

673
00:28:54,866 --> 00:28:54,899
[dramati                        

674
00:28:54,899 --> 00:28:54,933
[dramatic                       

675
00:28:54,933 --> 00:28:54,966
[dramatic st                    

676
00:28:54,966 --> 00:28:54,999
[dramatic stri                  

677
00:28:54,999 --> 00:28:55,033
[dramatic string                

678
00:28:55,033 --> 00:28:55,066
[dramatic string m              

679
00:28:55,066 --> 00:28:55,100
[dramatic string mus            

680
00:28:55,100 --> 00:28:55,133
[dramatic string music          

681
00:28:55,133 --> 00:28:55,967
[dramatic string music]         

682
00:29:00,605 --> 00:29:03,007
  - [Alan] Investigators have   
 matched the DNA found          

683
00:29:03,007 --> 00:29:04,709
   at the Wishart crime scene   

684
00:29:04,709 --> 00:29:07,278
 to a man named                 
  Elton Brutus Murphy.          

685
00:29:07,278 --> 00:29:11,716
 It's a huge break in the case, 
   but far from case closed.    

686
00:29:11,716 --> 00:29:13,852
   [intriguing music]           

687
00:29:13,852 --> 00:29:15,120
[ominous music]                 

688
00:29:15,120 --> 00:29:16,721
- [Mark] Even though we         
   had the DNA hit,             

689
00:29:16,721 --> 00:29:19,624
  that's not enough at          
that time for an arrest.        

690
00:29:19,624 --> 00:29:23,995
 Then there was a whole host of 
  other things we needed to do  

691
00:29:23,995 --> 00:29:27,766
to try and establish him        
   as the suspect in a crime.   

692
00:29:27,766 --> 00:29:29,000
   [intriguing music]           

693
00:29:29,000 --> 00:29:30,769
 - [Alan] How is this           
 man in a Houston jail          

694
00:29:30,769 --> 00:29:33,738
connected to a Sarasota         
  gallerist's murder?           

695
00:29:33,738 --> 00:29:35,140
   [intriguing music]           

696
00:29:35,140 --> 00:29:38,276
 - So, law enforcement          
   immediately went to Texas    

697
00:29:38,276 --> 00:29:39,144
   to interview him.            

698
00:29:39,144 --> 00:29:42,147
   [intriguing music]           

699
00:29:44,182 --> 00:29:48,019
   Detectives at the time did   
not know what to expect.        

700
00:29:48,019 --> 00:29:50,889
  They were hoping that this    
  person would speak to them.   

701
00:29:50,889 --> 00:29:52,757
   [intriguing music]           

702
00:29:52,757 --> 00:29:55,760
 As it turns out, Elton         
   did want to speak to them.   

703
00:29:55,760 --> 00:29:58,429
  He waived his right           
   to remain silent,            

704
00:29:58,429 --> 00:30:00,298
 which was somewhat unexpected. 

705
00:30:00,298 --> 00:30:02,901
   [intriguing music]           

706
00:30:02,901 --> 00:30:05,770
 - [Alan] The person detectives 
   meet in that Texas prison    

707
00:30:05,770 --> 00:30:07,338
 is stranger than they          
 could have imagined.           

708
00:30:07,338 --> 00:30:09,040
[ominous music]                 

709
00:30:09,040 --> 00:30:13,778
  - He said, "My name is the    
 Lord God Brutus Elton Murphy.  

710
00:30:14,145 --> 00:30:21,019
   I get my commands directly   
 from God, I work with aliens." 

711
00:30:32,797 --> 00:30:34,065
[ominous music]                 

712
00:30:34,065 --> 00:30:35,834
   - [Mark] And he elaborated   
  on us talking about           

713
00:30:35,834 --> 00:30:43,474
how he could hypnotize somebody 
and have sex with them.         

714
00:30:43,474 --> 00:30:47,478
  - [Dr. Casey] We usually see  
 this in crime novels, fiction, 

715
00:30:47,478 --> 00:30:49,247
 whether it's "Silence          
of the Lambs,"                  

716
00:30:49,247 --> 00:30:52,817
  where the person is           
  literally acting out a film   

717
00:30:52,817 --> 00:30:56,087
 that's in their head and their 
  mission and process focused.  

718
00:30:56,087 --> 00:30:57,488
   [intriguing music]           

719
00:30:57,488 --> 00:30:59,257
  - [Alan] Then Elton finally   
   gives them the connection    

720
00:30:59,257 --> 00:31:02,126
 to Joyce Wishart that          
 they've been seeking.          

721
00:31:02,126 --> 00:31:04,963
- [Suzanne] We found out that he
   actually lived in Sarasota   

722
00:31:04,963 --> 00:31:05,830
  at one time.                  

723
00:31:05,830 --> 00:31:08,233
   [intriguing music]           

724
00:31:08,233 --> 00:31:09,868
 He worked in Sarasota.         

725
00:31:09,868 --> 00:31:11,269
   [intriguing music]           

726
00:31:11,269 --> 00:31:14,739
 And then he tells law          
enforcement that he's an artist 

727
00:31:14,739 --> 00:31:22,413
 and he's been drawing quite a  
 bit while he's been in jail.   

728
00:31:22,413 --> 00:31:23,982
   [intriguing music]           

729
00:31:23,982 --> 00:31:26,150
   - [Mark] Elton brought up    
   several different places     

730
00:31:26,150 --> 00:31:28,119
   that he had tried            
   to sell his art,             

731
00:31:28,119 --> 00:31:33,224
   one of which was a shop in   
  Southgate Mall, in Sarasota,  

732
00:31:33,825 --> 00:31:35,426
 that he had gone into          

733
00:31:35,426 --> 00:31:39,430
 and offered them to sell some  
 of his artwork on consignment. 

734
00:31:39,430 --> 00:31:59,784
   [intriguing music]           

735
00:31:59,784 --> 00:32:02,153
  his art at flea markets and   
   different places.            

736
00:32:02,153 --> 00:32:06,024
He also did some art with plates

737
00:32:06,024 --> 00:32:08,293
   and was trying to            
  get buyers for them.          

738
00:32:08,293 --> 00:32:09,928
   [intriguing music]           

739
00:32:09,928 --> 00:32:11,529
 - [Mark] I believe he probably 
did go into the                 

740
00:32:11,529 --> 00:32:13,798
  Provenance Gallery.           

741
00:32:13,798 --> 00:32:18,036
   trying to have Ms. Wishart   
  sell his art on consignment.  

742
00:32:18,036 --> 00:32:19,938
   [intriguing music]           

743
00:32:19,938 --> 00:32:21,339
 - [Alan] The Sarasota          
detectives are confident        

744
00:32:21,339 --> 00:32:22,907
they have their killer,         

745
00:32:22,907 --> 00:32:26,945
   but can they get a           
  confession to seal the deal?  

746
00:32:26,945 --> 00:32:30,181
   - [Karen] Elton Murphy was   
   a cool character.            

747
00:32:30,181 --> 00:32:31,249
 [eerie music]                  

748
00:32:31,249 --> 00:32:35,586
He played cat and mouse         
   through three interviews.    

749
00:32:35,586 --> 00:32:39,057
 He thoroughly enjoyed          
 the contest of wills           

750
00:32:39,057 --> 00:32:42,060
between himself                 
  and the detectives,           

751
00:32:42,060 --> 00:32:49,834
  and he wasn't about           
  to admit anything.            

752
00:32:49,834 --> 00:32:56,507
   [intriguing music]           

753
00:32:56,507 --> 00:32:59,978
- [Mark] I think he felt he was 
  at a very high intelligence   

754
00:32:59,978 --> 00:33:01,479
 level and he could speak to us 

755
00:33:01,479 --> 00:33:05,483
and maybe play with us a        
  little bit in the interview,  

756
00:33:05,483 --> 00:33:08,086
   but not give any             
   good information.            

757
00:33:08,086 --> 00:33:12,090
- [Michael] I remembered one of 
 the motifs that investigators  

758
00:33:12,090 --> 00:33:13,958
find when they talked to        
   people in the area           

759
00:33:13,958 --> 00:33:17,095
 is that there had been         
  a man on a bicycle.           

760
00:33:17,095 --> 00:33:18,496
[ominous music]                 

761
00:33:18,496 --> 00:33:20,965
 - [Mark] Mr. Murphy did have a 
vehicle.                        

762
00:33:20,965 --> 00:33:23,968
  However, he had sold          
 it back to his brother         

763
00:33:23,968 --> 00:33:26,371
 and then was just using a bike 

764
00:33:26,371 --> 00:33:29,007
  the rest of the time          
   while in Sarasota.           

765
00:33:29,007 --> 00:33:30,241
[ominous music]                 

766
00:33:30,241 --> 00:33:32,977
- [Suzanne] And he freely admits
  that he was riding his bike   

767
00:33:32,977 --> 00:33:40,885
  around Sarasota the           
  day of the murder.            

768
00:33:40,885 --> 00:33:43,388
[ominous music]                 

769
00:33:43,388 --> 00:33:44,288
   - [Michael] Boom.            

770
00:33:44,288 --> 00:33:46,424
   [intriguing music]           

771
00:33:46,424 --> 00:33:49,560
And they arrest him and         
extradited him back to Sarasota.

772
00:33:49,560 --> 00:33:51,562
   [intriguing music]           

773
00:33:51,562 --> 00:33:55,666
 - When news broke that         
an arrest had been made,        

774
00:33:55,666 --> 00:33:59,137
   there was a giant            
   collective sigh of relief    

775
00:33:59,137 --> 00:34:01,572
 through the entire community.  

776
00:34:01,572 --> 00:34:04,175
Thank God someone's been caught.

777
00:34:04,175 --> 00:34:06,911
   [intriguing music]           

778
00:34:06,911 --> 00:34:09,580
 The killer was part of         
   the community for a while.   

779
00:34:09,580 --> 00:34:12,283
 He moved around a little bit,  

780
00:34:12,283 --> 00:34:14,318
   but he spent a great deal    
   of time in the community     

781
00:34:14,318 --> 00:34:18,022
  as a hairstylist, a barber,   

782
00:34:18,022 --> 00:34:20,591
   and people started           
  putting him together          

783
00:34:20,591 --> 00:34:23,694
 with the bicyclist and         
  the leather jacket.           

784
00:34:23,694 --> 00:34:24,929
   [intriguing music]           

785
00:34:24,929 --> 00:34:29,033
   - It was a palpable sense    
 of relief personally,          

786
00:34:29,033 --> 00:34:31,035
  you know, for the community.  

787
00:34:31,035 --> 00:34:35,706
  And the fact that hopefully   
  some justice would be done,   

788
00:34:35,706 --> 00:34:38,443
  some vindication of           
 this horrendous murder         

789
00:34:38,443 --> 00:34:39,577
   of my dear friend.           

790
00:34:39,577 --> 00:34:42,046
   [intriguing music]           

791
00:34:42,046 --> 00:34:43,448
 - [Alan] Elton Brutus          
 Murphy is in custody           

792
00:34:43,448 --> 00:34:45,616
and charged with                
  first-degree murder.          

793
00:34:45,616 --> 00:34:47,185
   [intriguing music]           

794
00:34:47,185 --> 00:34:50,621
But the road to a trial         
 is long and winding.           

795
00:34:50,621 --> 00:34:52,723
   - [Suzanne] So, one of the   
largest concerns                

796
00:34:52,723 --> 00:34:55,460
   was that Elton may           
be incompetent,                 

797
00:34:55,460 --> 00:34:58,096
  or found incompetent          
 before trial.                  

798
00:34:58,096 --> 00:35:02,233
   The doctors at this point    
give Elton a diagnosis,         

799
00:35:02,233 --> 00:35:04,368
schizoaffective                 
disorder, bipolar type,         

800
00:35:04,368 --> 00:35:06,604
  and he also suffers           
from delusions.                 

801
00:35:06,604 --> 00:35:08,239
   [intriguing music]           

802
00:35:08,239 --> 00:35:09,607
 The judge rules at the         
first competency hearing        

803
00:35:09,607 --> 00:35:11,742
 that he's incompetent,         

804
00:35:11,742 --> 00:35:15,613
  and he's sent to the Florida  
 State Mental Hospital          

805
00:35:15,613 --> 00:35:17,482
  for competency restoration.   

806
00:35:17,482 --> 00:35:20,084
   [intriguing music]           

807
00:35:20,084 --> 00:35:22,520
 - [Dr. Casey] When someone is  
  deemed mentally ill           

808
00:35:22,520 --> 00:35:25,323
 on such a severe scale         
  that they don't know          

809
00:35:25,323 --> 00:35:27,391
  what's going on around them   

810
00:35:27,391 --> 00:35:29,127
and, this is the                
important thing,                

811
00:35:29,127 --> 00:35:31,762
   can't assist with            
   their own defense,           

812
00:35:31,762 --> 00:35:34,532
  they could be ruled           
  incompetent to stand trial.   

813
00:35:34,532 --> 00:35:36,667
  It's a very different thing   
  than the insanity defense.    

814
00:35:36,667 --> 00:35:38,402
  The trial can't even happen.  

815
00:35:38,402 --> 00:35:40,371
   [intriguing music]           

816
00:35:40,371 --> 00:35:42,773
 - [Michael] He's treated with  
  psychotropic drugs,           

817
00:35:42,773 --> 00:35:46,644
 which are designed to          
stop his hallucinations.        

818
00:35:46,644 --> 00:35:48,112
 And they work.                 

819
00:35:48,112 --> 00:35:51,249
   [intriguing music]           

820
00:35:51,249 --> 00:35:55,253
  - [Suzanne] He would have a   
  competency hearing, be found  

821
00:35:55,253 --> 00:35:58,156
  incompetent, go to the state  
hospital for competency         

822
00:35:58,156 --> 00:35:59,423
restoration, and then come back,

823
00:35:59,423 --> 00:36:02,660
and then he would appear        
to be incompetent again.        

824
00:36:02,660 --> 00:36:03,794
   [intriguing music]           

825
00:36:03,794 --> 00:36:05,396
   - [Alan] Shuttling           
 back and forth                 

826
00:36:05,396 --> 00:36:08,132
 between the mental institution 
and the Sarasota courts         

827
00:36:08,132 --> 00:36:09,567
   goes on for years.           

828
00:36:09,567 --> 00:36:12,537
 [eerie music]                  

829
00:36:12,537 --> 00:36:20,811
 - The thing about Elton, he's  
 very, very, very mentally ill. 

830
00:36:20,811 --> 00:36:24,582
- [Suzanne] But we wondered just
  how much he was playing into  

831
00:36:24,582 --> 00:36:27,185
   this and how much            
   he was putting on            

832
00:36:27,185 --> 00:36:29,587
  to try and be found           
incompetent by the court        

833
00:36:29,587 --> 00:36:39,664
 because it was to his benefit. 

834
00:36:41,432 --> 00:36:44,402
   [intriguing music]           

835
00:36:45,970 --> 00:36:46,003
 [e                             

836
00:36:46,003 --> 00:36:46,037
 [eer                           

837
00:36:46,037 --> 00:36:46,070
 [eerie                         

838
00:36:46,070 --> 00:36:46,103
 [eerie m                       

839
00:36:46,103 --> 00:36:46,137
 [eerie mus                     

840
00:36:46,137 --> 00:36:46,170
 [eerie music                   

841
00:36:46,170 --> 00:36:47,505
 [eerie music]                  

842
00:36:49,240 --> 00:36:51,742
- [Alan] After three long years,

843
00:36:51,742 --> 00:36:54,145
  the persistence of            
  prosecutors finally results   

844
00:36:54,145 --> 00:36:57,615
 in Elton Brutus Murphy         
being declared competent        

845
00:36:57,615 --> 00:37:00,751
 to stand trial in the          
murder of Joyce Wishart.        

846
00:37:00,751 --> 00:37:02,119
[dramatic string music]         

847
00:37:02,119 --> 00:37:04,121
   - We knew we could           
prove he did it,                

848
00:37:04,121 --> 00:37:06,624
but we still had                
an uphill battle                

849
00:37:06,624 --> 00:37:08,259
  trying to get him to prison.  

850
00:37:08,259 --> 00:37:11,095
[ominous music]                 

851
00:37:11,796 --> 00:37:14,165
- When the trial finally began, 

852
00:37:14,165 --> 00:37:17,034
 it was a big deal in Sarasota. 

853
00:37:17,034 --> 00:37:19,870
  It was a very, very           
   high-profile case            

854
00:37:19,870 --> 00:37:22,873
  and, of course, the           
   suspense had been building   

855
00:37:22,873 --> 00:37:25,142
over years and years and years. 

856
00:37:25,142 --> 00:37:27,612
[ominous music]                 

857
00:37:27,612 --> 00:37:29,614
- [Suzanne] The biggest         
 challenge in the case against  

858
00:37:29,614 --> 00:37:41,626
  Elton Murphy was that he was  
   legitimately mentally ill.   

859
00:37:41,626 --> 00:37:44,929
[dramatic string music]         

860
00:37:44,929 --> 00:37:47,632
[dramatic string music]         

861
00:37:47,632 --> 00:37:49,033
   [intriguing music]           

862
00:37:49,033 --> 00:37:51,535
  - [Karen] So, all of us that  
   were involved in the case    

863
00:37:51,535 --> 00:37:52,803
  were on tenterhooks.          

864
00:37:52,803 --> 00:37:54,805
   [intriguing music]           

865
00:37:54,805 --> 00:37:57,775
 When it was the time           
for the defense experts         

866
00:37:57,775 --> 00:38:01,646
   to take the stand and talk   
about how they believed         

867
00:38:01,646 --> 00:38:06,183
 he should not be held          
 responsible as in go to prison 

868
00:38:06,183 --> 00:38:09,654
but should be locked up         
in a mental institution.        

869
00:38:09,654 --> 00:38:11,555
   [intriguing music]           

870
00:38:11,555 --> 00:38:14,558
 - [Suzanne] We knew that Elton 
   Murphy was insane,           

871
00:38:14,558 --> 00:38:17,662
 but we also knew that he knew  
  what he was doing was wrong   

872
00:38:17,662 --> 00:38:19,930
and he knew the                 
  consequences of his actions.  

873
00:38:19,930 --> 00:38:21,198
   [intriguing music]           

874
00:38:21,198 --> 00:38:23,567
 - [Alan] Convincing a          
jury is another matter.         

875
00:38:23,567 --> 00:38:25,102
   [intriguing music]           

876
00:38:25,102 --> 00:38:26,971
  - [Suzanne] The way we prove  
  that he knew                  

877
00:38:26,971 --> 00:38:30,941
 what he was doing was          
   wrong was by the cleanup.    

878
00:38:30,941 --> 00:38:33,344
  If someone doesn't            
 know that it's wrong,          

879
00:38:33,344 --> 00:38:34,578
 then why are they cleaning up? 

880
00:38:34,578 --> 00:38:35,980
   [intriguing music]           

881
00:38:35,980 --> 00:38:37,982
   The only reason a person     
 would clean in this situation  

882
00:38:37,982 --> 00:38:42,253
   is to avoid detection, to    
avoid showing evidence,         

883
00:38:42,253 --> 00:38:44,822
to avoid getting caught.        

884
00:38:44,822 --> 00:38:48,092
   And that's the hallmark of   
knowing that something is wrong.

885
00:38:48,092 --> 00:38:49,593
   [intriguing music]           

886
00:38:49,593 --> 00:38:51,862
   - [Alan] But one question    
  remains unanswered.           

887
00:38:51,862 --> 00:38:54,832
 Why did Elton Murphy           
 murder Joyce Wishart?          

888
00:38:54,832 --> 00:38:56,267
   [intriguing music]           

889
00:38:56,267 --> 00:38:57,835
 - [Mark] He considered         
   himself an artist.           

890
00:38:57,835 --> 00:38:59,236
   [intriguing music]           

891
00:38:59,236 --> 00:39:02,239
Maybe she rebuffed him,         
 did not like his art,          

892
00:39:02,239 --> 00:39:05,609
and that was enough for         
   him to be upset with her.    

893
00:39:05,609 --> 00:39:07,978
   [intriguing music]           

894
00:39:07,978 --> 00:39:10,014
But how he chose                
her as a victim,                

895
00:39:10,014 --> 00:39:12,383
   it could have been because   
 of the art connection.         

896
00:39:12,383 --> 00:39:14,151
   [intriguing music]           

897
00:39:14,151 --> 00:39:17,855
   - The time and effort that   
 was taken into posing the body 

898
00:39:17,855 --> 00:39:19,623
 and having the fingers         
   touch the magazine           

899
00:39:19,623 --> 00:39:21,992
and placing the artwork         
   around her head.             

900
00:39:21,992 --> 00:39:23,627
   [intriguing music]           

901
00:39:23,627 --> 00:39:26,997
 In his mind, everything he saw 
  was a potential movie scene   

902
00:39:26,997 --> 00:39:30,167
 or photograph to be preserved. 

903
00:39:30,167 --> 00:39:31,402
 An artistic creation.          

904
00:39:31,402 --> 00:39:38,042
   [intriguing music]           
 [door closes]                  

905
00:39:38,042 --> 00:39:40,911
[dramatic string music]         

906
00:39:40,911 --> 00:39:43,781
 - [Suzanne] Our message to the 
  jury in the end was,          

907
00:39:43,781 --> 00:39:46,317
   "This man is mentally ill,   

908
00:39:46,317 --> 00:39:48,152
  he is not criminally insane,  

909
00:39:48,152 --> 00:39:51,322
and he should be found          
  guilty and sent to prison."   

910
00:39:51,322 --> 00:39:52,757
[dramatic string music]         

911
00:39:52,757 --> 00:39:54,291
   - [Alan] While the           
   jury deliberates,            

912
00:39:54,291 --> 00:39:55,893
  prosecutors wait anxiously.   

913
00:39:55,893 --> 00:39:59,063
[dramatic string music]         

914
00:39:59,063 --> 00:40:04,135
- Oh, it's always nerve-wracking
when the jury goes out,         

915
00:40:04,435 --> 00:40:07,037
because you never know          
  what a jury is going to do.   

916
00:40:07,037 --> 00:40:08,172
[dramatic string music]         

917
00:40:08,172 --> 00:40:10,808
 - [Michael] I don't think that 
the prosecution thought         

918
00:40:10,808 --> 00:40:12,042
  it was a slam dunk.           

919
00:40:12,042 --> 00:40:13,911
[dramatic string music]         

920
00:40:13,911 --> 00:40:18,048
  There's always a chance that  
  there's going to be a juror   

921
00:40:18,048 --> 00:40:21,452
who says, "I can't convict this 
  guy, he's obviously crazy."   

922
00:40:21,452 --> 00:40:23,788
[dramatic string music]         

923
00:40:23,788 --> 00:40:26,090
- [Alan] When the jury          
returns to the verdict,         

924
00:40:26,090 --> 00:40:28,225
the courtroom holds its breath. 

925
00:40:28,225 --> 00:40:30,461
 [eerie music]                  

926
00:40:30,461 --> 00:40:34,465
 - [Karen] The jurors came back 
  with the verdict of guilty.   

927
00:40:34,465 --> 00:40:37,902
[dramatic string music]         

928
00:40:38,936 --> 00:40:40,070
 We were over the moon.         

929
00:40:40,070 --> 00:40:42,072
[dramatic string music]         

930
00:40:42,072 --> 00:40:45,810
 - [Mark] We were happy that he 
 was convicted of the homicide. 

931
00:40:45,810 --> 00:40:47,244
[dramatic string music]         

932
00:40:47,244 --> 00:40:49,980
 - [Suzanne] We worked so hard  
  for so many years,            

933
00:40:49,980 --> 00:40:53,083
   and so many people           
 were affected by this,         

934
00:40:53,083 --> 00:40:57,254
   and we felt an obligation    
   to the community             

935
00:40:57,254 --> 00:40:58,956
 to put this man away.          

936
00:40:58,956 --> 00:41:01,091
  He was so dangerous.          

937
00:41:01,091 --> 00:41:04,995
And to have that actually happen

938
00:41:04,995 --> 00:41:07,131
 was a highlight in my career.  

939
00:41:07,131 --> 00:41:10,868
[dramatic string music]         

940
00:41:10,868 --> 00:41:13,504
   [melancholic piano music]    
  [birds twittering]            

941
00:41:13,504 --> 00:41:18,809
 - [Jimmy] This episode of my   
life left me with a sense of... 

942
00:41:23,113 --> 00:41:28,285
   [melancholic piano music]    

943
00:41:28,285 --> 00:41:31,021
and he's never going to         
  see the light of day again.   

944
00:41:31,021 --> 00:41:33,290
   [melancholic piano music]    

945
00:41:33,290 --> 00:41:36,861
 - [Michael] Elton Murphy was a 
   dangerous and sick person.   

946
00:41:36,861 --> 00:41:39,763
The world is a much better place
  without him on the streets.   

947
00:41:39,763 --> 00:41:40,798
   [melancholic piano music]    

948
00:41:40,798 --> 00:41:44,301
 - [Linda] There was a certain  
   sense of relief.             

949
00:41:44,301 --> 00:41:45,769
   [melancholic piano music]    

950
00:41:45,769 --> 00:41:49,139
  But it didn't really          
 provide closure for me         

951
00:41:49,139 --> 00:41:54,144
because, to me, Joyce's         
   life will never be closed.   

952
00:41:55,012 --> 00:41:56,280
   [melancholic piano music]    

953
00:41:56,280 --> 00:41:59,283
And her great suffering         
  is still something            

954
00:41:59,283 --> 00:42:01,785
   that I carry inside of me.   

955
00:42:01,785 --> 00:42:03,320
   So I'm glad he's in jail,    

956
00:42:03,320 --> 00:42:05,556
  but I'm really sad            
that my friend is gone.         

957
00:42:05,556 --> 00:42:08,058
   [melancholic piano music]    

958
00:42:08,058 --> 00:42:11,295
- [Alan] The terrorized enclave 
took years to recover.          

959
00:42:11,295 --> 00:42:12,563
   [melancholic piano music]    

960
00:42:12,563 --> 00:42:16,033
   But through that process,    
  one truth emerged.            

961
00:42:16,033 --> 00:42:19,069
 Art itself has                 
   the power to heal.           

962
00:42:19,069 --> 00:42:21,472
  And for the artisans          
  and gallery owners,           

963
00:42:21,472 --> 00:42:24,308
   the healing only             
strengthened their bond         

964
00:42:24,308 --> 00:42:26,210
and their belief in it.         

965
00:42:26,210 --> 00:42:29,914
   [melancholic piano music]